David goes to my school were all cheering him on! hes great! Friday he prob coming to our school for a party american idol is hosting.

Go david MHS LOVES YOU!!!!

I completely agree with you [Dee-Dee]. David A might be able to sing. See I'm recognizing that, but he can ONLY sing ballads it seems. I might not think he's so bad if he stepped outside of his comfort zone for once. And I'd have to agree, he's like Melinda Doolitle last year. Yes, you know the judges love you. Quit acting like you haven't heard it the past 10 weeks or so.

And Wow, Jason I cannot believe how he is still on the show. A lot of girls say he's "pretty", but come on, the dude puts NO time into any of his work and it's extremely obvious.

Syesha actually surprised me tonight. Never been a big fan of her, but she does have an impressive voice. Though a little like every other week.

David Cook, just wow. I could not believe they thought David A beat everyone else. David Cook's rendition of The Who astounded me. His Duran Duran cover was a bit off, though a good cover non-the-less, being a fan of that song for a long time.

I guess the most we can ALL hope for is that Jason goes home before Syesha...haha

You are obviously tone deaf and clueless about music and talent....stick to what you know..nothing!

You went against yourself, for one thing.

Also, half of that stuff is made up.
[FAIL]

The expression is happiness. Would you be like, "Oh. Fine." if someone ever happened to compliment you? No? Ohh, burn. =|

Not very good? No comment. He's amazing. Can you sing that well, first of all? I don't think soo!

Never whispers under his breath, after anything happens. Kk.
And lordy... is lame. =/

Boring? Okaaay. Not many'll be with you on that.
Change the channel? Good for you.

You are nonsense. =]

Yupp... O_O
With that [wonderful] voice of his, he shouldn't have made it to Hollywood!

Dude, get a life. The kid's 17, and he's good. Jealousy is a diesese. Just saying.

Who are you to judge if he is fake or not? He belongs on the show because he has singing TALENT and that's what the whole show is about, right? Next time you judge who is fake or not, make you sure you really know them well enough to judge them.
Go David A!

I think someone is jealous!!! It seems that ALOT of people are jealous of David Archuleta! Maybe because he has something that they dont! & is poplular among most everyone! (except for the jelous ones of course) So shut the hell up! I bet you cant sing HALF as good as he can, & he is only 17!!!!!!!!!!!!

David Cook's performance was great but not individual. This exact arrangement was created by Chris Cornell and David replicated that. When you review Chris Cornell's version and the version David sang you will find that he is not as original as you thought, but rather a good researcher.

David Cook is the #1 download, followed closely by Brook White at #2 and Jason Castro and David A are tied around #3 and Michael Johns at #4. At $.99 per song, I think that illustrates quite conclusively that America likes their music.

Jason Castro fits well in his nitche, but is not versitile to be the next AI. We will have to see if he has any more hallelua's up his sleve. The world of music has a place somewhere for Jason Castro. If it can find a place for Cobie Callet, it definately has a place for Jason Castro

Michael Johns has a unique voice and stage presence out the kazoo - I predict he also wont be the next AI, but he will get a record deal and be at least in the top 4.

Brook White is beautiful, pure and unique in her own way. I predict she will also get a record deal and go far with this competition.

David A is a great kid with a very wonderful voice, but in my humble opinion is too young to be a sensation - he needed another couple of years unless he is to be picked up by the Miley Cirus show. He will be definately be a top 4 finalist.

David Cook is my pick for the next AI - he has it all and then some. and here is another word you can say for David C - consistant. No one hit wonder material here

I'd buy David A's CD.... not because he is a "cutie pie" but because he is amazingly talented.

David A is a cutie pie, no doubt, but he is too Disney to be a sensation, unless it is a teen sensation like Miley Sirus. I think David Cook definately has what it takes to go all the way.

Hey, idiot! what gave you the idea that Ramiele is just acting cute? That could be just her personality. And you think the other contestants are all real? You're the just jealous because you have nothing good to say about a person who may be really nice. Your words just shows what kind of a person you are!!!!

de1in...You ain't no Asian...so quit joking already you lying KKK redneck you.

If Cook wins that will be the time his bubble bursts. He will be worse than Taylor Hicks because his kind of music are for drug addicts and low-lifes. Not much money there.... He looks confident becuase he " has been there, done that". Not an Idol material at all. No matter how he dresses up his COMB OVER that looks like a very bad wig will spoil the whole enchalada. No class, no class.

You De1in ain't no Asian.....Even if you were you got it totally wrong..Ramile is no phony...she is acting her age of 20 young....one of the youngest among contestants. Has the most potential.

I'm not Asian either but we, thousands of my fellow Irish, are rooting for Ramiele..

When you talk about AI you are talking about a contestant's potential to be a recording star and not becuase the person has experience but flopped.

And it's all about youth, like it or not. They have ample room to improve. Unlike the older ones.

So just CHILL out......

actually, David A. is the best so far.
he's got great vocals, sweet personality, the right look, and tonssssss of talent.
and even though he messed up last week doesn't mean he's not going to make a come back and blow everyone away like he did from the very start.

David A. for the win!

hey u De1in! don't u think you're the phony one? maybe you can't even sing! do you know what constructive criticism is? you might be an asian but you belong to those uneducated ones! just shut up if u have nothing good to say to the candidates... duh!

I agree that Jason Castro is good and I thought he was better than everyone said he was tonight. He has a great look and a great strong voice. The other Jason needs to go. I do like all 3 of the David's though and I hope they all make it to the top 12.

asia eferson looks like a gorilla and acts so ghetto ...not a lady

i agree with you. i think that blake is far more complete as a performer, and cannot wait to see how good he will get. he has such a dreamy, pretty voice.
i dont think jordin sparks lacks talent, but i do think she is vocally limited. she sings big, and loud and screeches. she sings one note, loud. american audiences think this means good. it doesnt. every time she has a song other than a weepy, dull ballad, she does not do well at all. AT ALL. i dont think the judges understand singing or music at all. they think there is one way to be good. would nora jones have done well on this show?

and i find jordin lacks sincerity. her tears seemed fake.

not as bad as katharine mcphee from before though. she was terrible. her mother should have aborted her. she is racist and stupid and a bitch.

it comes down to this: do the 14 yr old girls want jordin as their best friend, or blake as their boyfriend? melinda was their mom. im guessing jordin will win, because she is safe and dull and good and cute. i do hope blake goes on to have a musical career like chris daughtrey.

but whats funny is how everyone knows melinda doolittle was the one who should have won. like al gore.

why you hate Mexicans so much? maybe you are SO ignorant that you don't know a great part of this country BELONGED TO MEXICO before the US took it over. Obviously you have a problem and you should see a therapist ASAP to get rid of all that hate you have inside...because it only hurts YOURSELF. Try to think clearly. She's only 17 and she's already a great singer. Both of them deserve to be idols, but you can't think that much, that's TOO DEEP for your minuscule brains.