The Contestants:

I personally think Elliot is the underdog who showed the entire world that he can do what needs to be done. His performance and singing was right on tonight. Katherine was off tonight, but she has been pretty consistent throughout the competition and she is an outstanding singer.  Chris was average tonight.  He has had better performances.  Taylor needs to go home.  I am tired of his short versions of songs where he does more dancing than singing.  Yes, I agree he is a performer but that is not the entire competition. 

The Judges:

Paula is driving me absolute crazy this season.  She is over emotional and I am getting so tired of her interupting Simon when it is his turn to speak. I wonder if she goes home and thinks, 'how ridiculous was I tonight.' I wish Simon would put her in her place one of these nights.  I find her rude and obnoxious this season. 

Simon has been right on this season, except for perhaps one or two nights, with a couple of contestants, but other than that RIGHT ON.  He takes each performance for that performance.  He does not take in effect that last time the contestant performed.  I wish the other two would judge appropriately and not base it on if they like the person or not and not base it on their last performance.

Randy is okay.  Sometimes he is right on, but lately he seems to be following in Paula's footsteps,which is not a strategic or intelligent move. I wish he would judge appropriately and stick to judging; his outbursts make him look incompetent sometimes. 

Okay  What is American Favorite Idol all about?   you are right  entertainment   and Taylor has it  

Kat has the looks and voice and she knows she has a record deal already  and so does Chris  so don't worry fans you will see them again.

Elliot if he is serious  about a record  he must get plastic surgery     he has the voice   so get to it and spend$$$$$

to get a record cut deal    

Yes Paula is very annoying. She doesn't give Simon a chance to speak out. And her emotional outbursts makes her look like a drama queen. They really need to replace her.

All of the idol finalists were good this year. I think some producer should consider a Taylor HIcks, and Katt duet album awesome.

The rockers never seem to make it to the top spot. Maybe they need to keep the lines open longer. Or a recount.

Please, please, please vote for ELLIOT.  His voice is great (only, when he does a Stevie Wonder, he sounds dodgy!).  Does any one know the "Going Home"  song he did a few weeks back?  Who's it by originally, please?!!