I cannot believe that everyone who voted for these men who are remaining didn't get a clue!!  Hello America.  You could see that these men were lucky.  The cannot hold a note to Crystal OR Siobhan.  Siobhan is young but she is inspiring.  How many of you have felt if you only had a second chance.  With grooming and guidance, someone to take her under their wings... WATCH OUT AMERICA...Siobhan is a star ready to burst.

 

Hey Siobhan, you are the best, made the show most interesting and unusual.  The crowned ones dont normally make it!!!!! :)  Look how many crowned ones are at the top.  Maybe 2.

You will be tops, work at it, your talent is unique.  The rest all sound the same.

Good Luck and look forward to your records.

Yes

the whole point of the judges save is for something like this.... They really wasted it on Mike. Yes he has a good voice, but the Judges  are also looking at marketability and Mike constantly hits his chest and grins like 'hes the man'....its really arrogant and annoying.  He will not win.  Siobhan might not have won either, though her voice is amazing, but she should have at least been in the bottom 3.  Because now there is no competition,

But I also feel like Siobhan didn't want to play the hollywood game.  Which is fine.  I think she can find a different place for her voice in the industry.

 

But really, her clarity and tone is amazing.  With every other performer besides Crystal you cross your fingers that they hit the notes.. That is ridiculous.  I can't just listen to the songs like I did last year with Kris and Adam or Alison, because I feel like its still the top 24 and you're hoping they pic the right song and can hit all the notes.  When Siobhan comes to sing, I don't have to worry, I can just listen to her, because she always hits the notes....bleh, what a waste.

 

 

Siobhan Magnus was the most talented person on American Idol, whether you realize it or not. NOBODY could pull off her scream and NOBODY was as interesting, quirky, or eye-catching as she was.

P.S. This is when the judge's save should have been used. It was completely wasted on Big Mike. He's so theatrical and fake that it's truly sickening. If he wins American Idol, then Season 10 has truly gone down the shitter.

siobhan casey crystal lee u all the best

Siobohn you have best talent of all the contestants and will win the American Idol title. Remember last year that although David Archuletta got all the votes and accolades the other contestant David Lambert who was second choice of many won. WHY? Because he had Marketable talent and he was not afraid to show it. You have all that he had and has you will ultimately be a money winner for the show and all the judges know it. That is why they are building up the controversy. You are a Barbara Striestand, Judy Garland, Linda Ederle and Cecile Dion all wrapped up in one and you are still you. Believe in yourself, you are going to go far if you do that. You know who you are now and do not forget that. Come back this next week and blow all of their socks off. Make them sit up and take notice of you for what and who you are.

Siobhan you are really perfect i love you !!!

I have watched American Idol over the years as well as America’s Got Talent and Britain’s Got Talent. We have all seen great talent and stars as a result. The judging, for the most part, has been fair and meant to provide constructive criticism – until American Idol 2010! It is clear to me that Randy, Kara and Simon have all decided who they want to win and, for the first time ever, I see them being overly hard on one contestant, Siobhan Magnus. Siobhan has the best voice of all of the contestants this year. She, by far, outshines everyone. Further, she is the only contestant who comes each week to entertain the audience and not the judges. She brings excitement in her vocal style and her very interesting wardrobes. While I am not in the industry such as Kara and Simon, thus do not wield the influence as they, I am an appreciator of talent and know it when I see/hear it and Siobhan is one of the best I have ever seen over the 60 years I have been enjoying similar talent. As I read the comments posted on the net, I am appalled at some of the capriciously negative remarks that are not warranted or justified in any way except personal bias. Siobhan’s demeanor has been maligned for no purpose other than to be critical. Her presence on stage has been nothing short of professional in the face of such unjustified negative comments from the judges that would make people of less character quit. Siobhan is not a quitter and she is not deserving of anything less than the ravest reviews for her performances as they out do Whitney Houston and Maria Carey just to be specific. She is a rare vocal talent that is exceptional and worthy of our protection from the political criticism dished out to keep her from overtaking the judge’s preferred favorite. The judging should be left in the hands of the audience. Randy, Kara and Simon need to refrain from tarnishing a truly bright star, Siobhan Magnus. Of all the American Idol contestants, Siobhan is the only contestant I would pay to go see and hear.

I am so baffled as to why she is still here, or how she even got on the show.  Is it cause they needed let one retard through, or what? She is terrible, and I always fast-forward through her SCREAMING...which the judges have consistantly told her to stop doing, and just sing...I can't wait for her to go home and just go back to like waiting tables or something where people don't have to suffer anymore at the hand of her yelling and hideous clothing!!

Siobhan Do not listen to any of thses critics. Your direction is to follow foor steps of great artists such as Lisa Gerrard. Please listen to her music. i know you will know what i mean. Your purity and shapeless talent is pure artistic and all you need is to go in and find that pure light. create your own genre. It is a gift that commercial Music will never understand the debth. you got the voice and the base for building a music of your own. I am glad Kerra doesn't know who you are. It is the sign of pure artistic talent that is in search of the light within. I belive in you. If you get this contact me, i will discuss more with you.

Thank You

Siobhan is.... A REAL STAR!!!!!!!!!!!

The best singer to the season,, whit an amazing voice and with so much talent... for me one of the best idol contestants ever... like Kelly Clarkson,Daughtry or Adam ,, you're just amazing, everytime i see you i think that's a concert not a contest you're the best because you're relevant and umpredicteable not like Crystal that's just good and that's all,,, i mean she has nothing to compite with your talent

keep going and You Will be the Next AI and real star!!!!!!!!!!!

Siobhan you are not only a beautiful singer but also a beautiful person and I love the way you dress your self up different each time keep it up and remember this Adam Lambert may not have won AI but look how it does not bother him and he is fantastic it would be great to see both of you sing together

You're awesome, Siobhan.  I've never watched the show before and don't like it because I don't think much of the judges and I wonder how much of it is staged or pre-planned.  But any way, you are absolutely the greatest!  You are impressive and individual and sensitive.  I wish you the best.

 

Cape Cod, NY is near wear the Boston Yankees play quidditch against the Hyannis Mets.

 

Mars Tons Mills is ackshully on another planet.  Watch out for that fish wearing a cloak (The Caped Cod).

Dear Siobhan, I'm Iqbal from Indonesia, hope you can find it on the world map, haha...

No Doubt, you're amazing and fantastic singer, and you look so pretty on TV Camera. You are the real Idol since you were born. Thank God you're there and show the world how great you are.

My family & I, usually don't really follow AI.  But once in a while, contestants like you keep it interesting & fun to watch.  For many fans like me, you are hands down 'THE BEST'.  No one, including CB comes close to you.  Keep it up.

 

 

By far you are the best ... simon is just trying to make the show lively by supporting Crystal -- keep doing the high notes at the end - even add some in the middle like Adam Lambert would do --  it will take you on to win this!!!

I really like your voice, and your look. you are doing so good. You can sing so pure and clean. I realy enjoy every song you are singing. you are very different. Keep up the good work. You can touch notes so low and so high that no contestant at this point in time can do it. Good luck, Hope you are the next American Idol.

I'm not sure which town is where, i just know that she is easily my favorite on the show, awesome tonite as always, best of luck Siobhan !

And its not even a town - its a region - but I'll cut you slack there since that's where she introduces herself as being from.