Again, Playing it Safe is not good at this point .  Our Idol Watch Group feels that we want to see more creativity.  Chris is not; Ace is not; Kellie is; Taylor is; Paris is; Elliott is somewhat; Katherine needs to show more; and Bucky tried...  We have been Idol Fans througout Season 4 and Season 5 without missing a minute.  Carrie showed she deserved the title of the American Idol in Season 4, and has proved it over the past 11 months; whereas Bo Bice has drifted off into some other world.   Although there still exists some good contestants in Season 5, they are going to have to get after it and show their creativity and versitility in the next couple of weeks or be a one time winner.  Don't get me wrong they all have talent.  But, there is only one or two that if they win will have a following, no matter how they are marketed, after they receive the title.