Get your American Idol songs hereicon
The Critic's blog

David Cook wins American Idol 2008

Submitted by The Critic on Wed, 2008-05-21 20:02

Congratulations to David Cook on a great win with a more than 12million vote majority - dare I say the biggest victory in Idol history?

Leave your congratulations in the comments below

»

I am so glad that David Cook

I am so glad that David Cook won and seems to be doing well. I think he is a genuine nice guy.

David Archuleta is so Q!!!!!

David Archuleta is so Q!!!!!

Congrats! now that AI is

Congrats!
now that AI is over you should all check out Nashville Star!! its on Mondays on NBC!! I love it and Taylor Swift will be the guest and she is sooooo cute!

I was glad to see Dabid Cook

I was glad to see Dabid Cook win the contest. I probably voted for him 60-70 times.

I LOVE David Cook, and I`m

I LOVE David Cook, and I`m just SO happy he won, I`m from México and I can´t wait to buy his album... I have never been an American Idol fan, but this guy have "something"... Congratulations to him! he is gonna be very famous :)

Check out my David Cook's

Check out my David Cook's Fan Page with lyrics of the winner song "The Time Of My Life" and many other songs, pictures, free mp3 downloads and much more stuff about David before he was the American Idol winner.

Cheers, Milou

David Cook is going to sell

David Cook is going to sell SOOOOOOO MANY records.

I couldn't even vote for him (In Canada) but he put out a familiar vibe that I felt when I heard Kelly. Clay and Kalan Porter (Canadian Idol Winner...kick ass musician). If he is allowed to make the record I think he wants to, woah, big things are going to happen.

It was time for an older person who knows what they want in a career to win AI. David is the shiznit.

meanwhile .. on PLANET

meanwhile .. on PLANET MARS...

pictures are HERE

enjoy ;-)

I've been reading all these

I've been reading all these comments and all you people take it so personally!! Yet some are in here tearing each other apart over what a talent show??!! Man there's so much more in this world for us to get pissed about for instance GAS prices! people in countries dieing from not being allowed to get aid such as the victims of the cyclone.... now that is something to be upset about. When will be put things in perspective?
Peace to all.

Voice from Asia.. I don't

Voice from Asia.. I don't know what happend but I must say DAVID ARCHULETA is THE GUY and he REALLY ROCKS! I am not saying David Cook is no good but David Archuleta is the best of the best!

We Asian loves David Archuleta!!!

hmm .. well, i do see more

hmm .. well, i do see more archuleta's supporters here, but i think david cook got plenty of supporters as well.
but i believe many people in asia love david archuleta and david cook.

Please do not speak in

Please do not speak in behalf of us.

Little David is so cute, and

Little David is so cute, and give him credit cos for a 17 year old, his vocal control is amazing. Of course he's still young and inexperienced, but he has the talent and with years of experience he can develop his own style and personality. I would have loved to hear him sing his song from Dream Girls. But everytime he sings he gives me chills.

Little David won the

Little David won the final.

Big David won the season.

Congratulations to David

Congratulations to David Cook on his triumphant win last night On American Idol. I personally don't find him attractive but he has a great singing voice. I really liked when he sang Billy Jean he really made that song his own. Archuleta, I liked at first but then he became pretty boring for a young guy. Plus he displayed no personality when speaking the little shy boy got pretty old quick!

David Cook is the most

David Cook is the most talented person they have ever had on idol and more than deserved to win. Finally America gets it right and crowns the original and daring rocker. He will be hugely successful, and thats just what they needed. He owns so many of the best performances ever on Idol. What a lovely guy he is too. So sweet and humble. When he won the first thing he thought to do was console Archie and applaud him. What a guy. All this on top of having a brother dying of cancer and supporting a little girl with cancer by wearing that orange bracelet every week. He's a true Idol in every sense of the word.

Best Idol ever.

been watching american idol

been watching american idol 4 many yrs now. David Cook is by far the most awesome contestant eva. I wish him all the luck 4 his amazing career that i know he will have.

Good one america!!!!!!!!
from new zealand viewer

I´m from Venezuela and I

I´m from Venezuela and I love American Idol since the first time I watched it.

This time I thought only DC and DA had the right to win. I love AC, he´s such a great singer. DC is amazing!!!! he´s so intelligent and he looks like a star

I´m pretty sure both of them will be the bomb for different targets. Personally I´m so happy that DC won it, he´s more the kind of artist I like

Regards to everybody

dont know about all of you,

dont know about all of you, but honestly david cook, is NOT the hottest thing since sliced bread. he has a receding hair line, and he needs a shave.

that being said. David archuletta (tarantula?) He did not SUIT my tastes. He has a wonderful stage career ahead of him, possibly playing some amazing part in a broadway musical. This is not a diss, i love musicals.

I did not like his voice as a current musician, Cook may have done some original work, he may have borrowed other versions of the "lame" show lists they had this year, but he had the ability to get it done.

He also has the range to get it done. Not the octave range, but the muscial range, from rocker to ballad to even rock ballad, not many people have that ability.

I know that the archulettaites are really angry right now. I understand that, I know that the Cookies are just estatic. Just realize that none of what we say matters now. It's over, it's done with, and the two will either rise from this heroes or fade into oblivion.

Don't know about you but I've yet to hear a number one from ruben studdard, fantasia, and after that my idol knowlege waxes and wanes.

I seriously hope Cook kept enough interest that he can pull a great career out of this shenanigan, but if he can't at least he had the chance to be something for a while, and i'm glad I got to hear his vocals in the meantime.

Simon issued his retraction

Simon issued his retraction (probably because the producers gave him the heads up on the fix at the last minute) and Archuleta looked like he knew the results before it was announced (probably because his Dad/Manager wouldn't play ball with the American Idol producers).

The only one who looked suprised was David Cook! Obviously they have different styles buy even he knows he couldn't hold a note next to Archuleta.

Cook will disappear into nothingness like his last generic band did, no matter how much money they throw at him and Archuleta's undeniable natural talent is going to make some lucky producer filthy stinkin' rich even if his Dad IS a pain in the ass.

Hopefully Cook will invest whatever loot he can pull out of this and spin it into some sound investments for his retirement.

You have to wonder why the results are concealed and scrutinized by the producers and the producers alone.

Did you even watch the show?

Did you even watch the show? I mean honestly? How many songs from David Cook were amazing, original, and alive? How many songs from David A were boring, the same sound, and very much dead. DC has the ability to be more than just a singer, he is extremly talented, and extremly progressive. DA started with Imagine and Ended in Imagine....so he had ZERO progression, he never changed, he didnt get better he stayed the same...very weak very very WEAK. David Cook IS so much better than the little werido who has no stage presence, no individuality, all he can do is sing he's not a American Idol...plan and simple.

Why should David Archuleta

Why should David Archuleta have to change his style? I like his consistency in keeping his vocals under control every week, without having to shout or change his style just to win votes. He gave his all at the finals and I belive that he won the finale, even if he didn't win the season.

hey idol fans, i think that

hey idol fans, i think that either one of the Davids deserved to win and have the oppertunity to sing more to the world!!!!!!

also congatulations to David Cook 4 winning A.I

Oh how original...an

Oh how original...an Archuleta fan ripping on Cook because he triumphed (and rightfully so). You know what, since you like him so much how about you take some tips on how to behave like a gracious loser from him.

It wasn't "fixed". Dial idol which measures busy signals on the AI phone lines and has done for last 4 seasons predicted without a shadow of a doubt and by a huge margin that David Cook would win based on their data.

Also the better singer won.

You will be eating your words in no time about his career.

Already actually. DC hold the top 4 spots on itunes america right now.

Archie is a sweet kid and very gracious in defeat. Too bad you cant say the same for his rabid fans.

I wouldn't say that I was an

I wouldn't say that I was an Archuleta fan. My opinions are based on the clarity and the quality of the vocals. I'm not a Seyesha fan either and she was far and away, above DC's abilities as well. I just don't find the results credible for the quality of the performances that were produced.

I have seen Collective Soul, live at a small venue about ten years ago and I'll never forget it - it was crystal clear. David Cook was pitching all over the place and I'm sure the Collective Soul boys were cringing at every butchered note. Come on now, lets be honest and I don't buy that "making it his own crap". He can't sing the song and that's that.

I forgot that Taylor Hicks guy's name until recently and I doubt if I'll remember who David Cook is a year from now either.

I agree with you. Little

I agree with you. Little David can control his vocals better than any 17 year old I know. David Cook is a pop star, he can scream and shout like any other pop star does, at least David Archuleta doesn't do that.

*lol* fantasy boy. the

*lol* fantasy boy. the reality is David Cook is significantly better than Archuleta, that's why Cook won.
what kind of excuses are you going to make up when Cooks is the best selling American Idol of all time - because it's going to happen - fact. start making up stuff for that so you'll be ready. m0r0n!!!

CAREFUL! dammit man! keep

CAREFUL!

dammit man! keep it down! *whispering* they are everywhere, they have people listening and watching always… you make one comment too much about the super-secret conspiracy and they will wisp you away to the land of merr and you will spend your days with elvis and the martians.

*backs out of the room with darting motions from side to side*

real original - "backs out

real original - "backs out of the room" thing has been done.

It's no secret, nor is it a conspiracy that the producers don't wan't anything to do with Archuleta's Dad and as it is in any business, the management is responsible for manipulating it's interests. Archuleta will do just fine without them.

NEWSFLASH! So has the

NEWSFLASH!

So has the conspiracy theories been done to death.

I am sorry David A. did not win, honestly… We can agree on one thing, he will do very well without them.

(sorry I am arguing some of your other posts too because I am bored and not tired…)

While I will go along with Idol attempting to sway votes in their interests (be stupid not to), the fact remains that an independent company does the voting tally's… sure they could be rigged but when do you just put your trumpets down and say… Ok, he won… Arch. lost. time to go back to life.?

Syesha has a brilliant voice, fantastic stage pres. I will give you that, what she is not is… David Cook. David A is not either.

David Cook is Marketable. He is perfect age, young, no baggage, bright smile, seems confident, poised, likable (by non Archie fans lol), seems to be genuine (I am not like most of the idiots on here that presume to KNOW the idols lol) and he reaches the a wider demographic than syesha or David A. and that's what won him idol.

People seem to miss the one important fact about this damn show… It's not all about the damn singing voice!!! It's about the damn votes!! It's not about the quality of the body of work!!! It's about the votes!!! How many times on here have people dropped words like vibrato, pitch, range, tonal quality… WHOOP! If the largest mass of people liked the off-key pitch and votes… it don't mean JACK!

You speak of business like you have experience and knowledge of it and I am sure you will recognize that any business that wishes to thrive markets itself and creates a brand identity that delivers flash and sparkle with great tag lines that elevate itself to it's audience… it's what sells. David Cook sells.

Steve Jobs had the best operating system in the late 80's a massively better product than Bill Gates and was going to storm the word with the "Apple computer" Only to have the rug pulled out from him by Gates that put a more sellable product on the shelf first called DOS on an IBM… Apple was the better computer, IBM out sold it by getting to market and giving the majority of people what they "wanted" while Jobs held back perfecting the apple to give people "perfection" and what he felt people needed.

Perfection is not marketable anymore. TONS of people prefer to hear "raw" edgy voices that do make mistakes, as opposed to studio revamped/remixed/unreal content. Acoustic versions, real versions. "polished voices" have no place in Rock is far as I am concerned and Rock IS still the mass leader in music content. David A is fantastic at pulling your heart string and giving you that sad hopeful feeling when he sings. Cook makes you want to drive faster, push it to the edge… reach down and feel your heart pounding and jump out of the plane, he's a rush, he's a rocker! He just happened to be good enough to also have a good enough voice to pull off the ballads when he had too.

MOVE ON ARCH FANS, MOVE ON.

if the there is no fix then

if the there is no fix then the results were most certainly manipulated as "becbau" has suggested here:

Here's my take. The producers and judges wanted Cook. Fine, he really is a great performer and he won fair and square. I really like Cookie. But, they were afraid Lil Dave might win and they did everything they could to manipulate the results, which by the way I believe, were actually that lopsided. First they gave Lil Dave the knockout punch routine to lull his fans into false sense of security and not worry about voting. Second, leaving the lines open for 4 hours knowing the demographic of Lil Dave's fans in the east and central time zones would not be able to stay up past their bedtimes to vote until 12 and 1 oclock to keep voting. I think the wink at Cook following the criticism of his third song was meant as "trust me I know what I'm doing". Are the results fixed - no. Are they manipulated - no doubt in my mind - yes!!!!!!!

Hi everybody I am from

Hi everybody

I am from Barbados and i had David Cook to win weeks ago. Finally America voted right and by so much wow. David C is so versatile and sexy, that is why he won. Dont get me wrong i love David A too but he is young and now wants nuturing.

so you AMericans who are sore about the results GET OVER IT....the best man won hahahhahahhahahah
WOOOOHOOOOOOOOOOO

I get really tired of all

I get really tired of all the haters that say Archuleta is a one-trick pony. Yes, David A. did do alot of ballads this season because he was smart enough to know that they showcased his talent the best. It got him to the finale now didn't it. However, he really does have the ability to do other music. His renditions of the up-tempo Sweet Caroline and America were superb. I also liked his version of Dont Let the Sun Go Down on Me. Not exactly up-tempo but still a worthy song. He does need to work on his stage presence though especially in the more upbeat songs. But last night during his performances with OneRepublic and his duet with Cookie, he showed that he can do timely pieces and still rock the house. I, for one, would definitely buy that kind of CD. So. Jeff, do your boy right and please, please, please market him right. Make sure he does contemporary music not remix of old Sinatra cuts.

David Cook's smashing

David Cook's smashing "American Idol" victory continues to bring immediate attention to his home of Blue Springs and the KC area. But what's the longterm effect here? Probably not much, frankly.

Sure, Cook will get a record contract. He will tour with the other "Idol" finalists. And I'm sure he will have some kind of homecoming concert in this area, bringing out his screaming fans.

But the kind of mania that swept the KC area regarding Cook will be short-lived. The "Cook rocks" signs will go into hibernation.

He will soon become one of the thousands of artists competing for the hard-earned dollars of music fans.

Cook will enjoy some fame because of his success on a TV show. But that won't sustain a career, as Jordin Sparks and a few other "Idol" winners have discovered to their dismay.

Cook will have to survive on his own talent, which is considerable.

David Cook's smashing

David Cook's smashing "American Idol" victory continues to bring immediate attention to his home of Blue Springs and the KC area. But what's the longterm effect here? Probably not much, frankly.

Sure, Cook will get a record contract. He will tour with the other "Idol" finalists. And I'm sure he will have some kind of homecoming concert in this area, bringing out his screaming fans.

But the kind of mania that swept the KC area regarding Cook will be short-lived. The "Cook rocks" signs will go into hibernation.

He will soon become one of the thousands of artists competing for the hard-earned dollars of music fans.

Cook will enjoy some fame because of his success on a TV show. But that won't sustain a career, as Jordin Sparks and a few other "Idol" winners have discovered to their dismay.

Cook will have to survive on his own talent, which is considerable.

ok, just keep saying that to

ok, just keep saying that to yourself, you might be able to convince yourself :)

Here's my take. The

Here's my take. The producers and judges wanted Cook. Fine, he really is a great performer and he won fair and square. I really like Cookie. But, they were afraid Lil Dave might win and they did everything they could to manipulate the results, which by the way I believe, were actually that lopsided. First they gave Lil Dave the knockout punch routine to lull his fans into false sense of security and not worry about voting. Second, leaving the lines open for 4 hours knowing the demographic of Lil Dave's fans in the east and central time zones would not be able to stay up past their bedtimes to vote until 12 and 1 oclock to keep voting. I think the wink at Cook following the criticism of his third song was meant as "trust me I know what I'm doing". Are the results fixed - no. Are they manipulated - no doubt in my mind - yes!!!!!!!

I'm actually a bit shocked

I'm actually a bit shocked that America made the right choice. It seems that, most of the time, we're very short-sighted in our decisions and go with what's fluffy, shiny and cute. I had pretty much resigned myself to a David A win, but I'm glad that someone who seems to have a very genuine personality, decent looks, modesty, wit, a sense of humor, a lot of creativity and a rough but powerful voice pulled through and was victorious by several million votes. This is the equivalent of the smart, cute girl that you love to hang out with winning the beauty pageant instead of the fake-tanned, fake-breasted obnoxious girl. Sure, the latter is always fun to look at for a few minutes, but in the end, most folks will prefer someone who has substance and character, not just an adorable smile. Both Davids will have decent careers, at least for a little while, but I will actually purchase David C's record (I've never even thought about purchasing an Idol contestant's record before this) whereas I would never purchase a David A record. What folks in the David C camp seem to understand is that this competition is about more than just having a flawless voice - we can build robots with those. It's about having the complete package, including several layers of intangibles that allow an individual to identify and relate to other people and win their hearts and minds.

Congratulations, David Cook. You've earned it.

What are you David A. fans

What are you David A. fans talking about? Not that it even matters what you guys think anymore since DC won it fair and square and it wasn't even close!!! DC deserved it more than anyone in Idol history! Please stop bashing and be happy for both of them. David A. knew that he was going to lose because what he had done all season didn't compare to what DC had done over and over every week! DC just looked like a star last night. He had it all.. the voice, the looks, the whole entire package! I even got all teary eyed especially when they told him he won he gave David A. a big hug and had everyone clap for him. America finally made the right choice! I LOVE YOU DAVID COOK, I CAN'T WAIT FOR YOUR ALBUM!!!

concerned citizen The

concerned citizen
The sentence should read "making complete fools of yourselves" not "making complete fools of yourselfs".

If you're going to rabbit on about spelling and pronunciation, at least get your own right. :-)

Dear all...it does not

Dear all...it does not matter who win or lose! It is just a beginning for all of them. They need our support instead. To me American idol is a dream for everyone, who are them before Americon idol? Today who are them after the Americon idol? It is about changing your life! Your dream! Within few months, many stars are born! I call this miracle, I call this fantasy! Please do keep support american idol, please do keep all our dream come true! Thank you American Idol... CHEERS!

George Michael was

George Michael was definitely the best contestant on the night! :-)

Just have to post a note.

Just have to post a note. After reading some of the blogs, it's amazing to me how cruel and un-intelligent some of you are. First of all if your going to hate on someone - get out the dictionary and spell the words correctly. Also check with your english teachers because most of you are slaudering the english language. I even read one comment about a racial bias. Please this is a reality TV show that America votes on. I'm sure the few of you that are stating they will not watch next year will be replaced with new viewers because David Cook won. I watched every episode from the auditions to the finale and never once did I see David Cook use the sickness of his brother to his advantage. Actually it was released by the press to America. He never brought it up. I had a relative die of cancer 2 years ago and I find the statements made in here appalling. Maybe some of you should try night school to educate yourselves before making complete fools of yourselfs in front of America.

Congratulations to both David's and I think America made the right choice

"slaudering?" "yourselfs?"

"slaudering?" "yourselfs?" "un-intelligent?" hahahahaha!!! You better check with your Webster there "Mister Wizard". Thank you for your astute comments on the English language. LOLOLOL!!! The correct spelling is "slaughtering" and it's either "yourself" or "yourselves" - there's no such thing as "yourselfs". Oh, and by the way, there's no hyphen in the word "unintelligent". In addition, when you are referring to the English language you must capitalize the letter "E". These are elmentary school level errors for such a prestigious scholar such as yourself! Maybe you should get out the dictionary and spell the words correctly! LOLOLOL!!! My guess is that you must be less than twelve years old or maybe you should ask the "night school" that you attended for your money back (before you make a fool out of yourself in front of America). LOLOLOL!!!!!!!!

As far as American Idol goes - who cares! Your rediculous, uneducated rant just made my day.

You really have the right to

You really have the right to preach about spelling.

1. Yourselves and not yourselfs.
2. Slaughtering and not slaudering.

3. You're and idiot!!!!!!!!!

concerned citizen The

concerned citizen
The sentence should read "making complete fools of yourselves" not "making complete fools of yourselfs".

If you're going to rabbit on about spelling and pronunciation, at least get your own right.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

How supprised....... Cook

How supprised.......

Cook won because...

a). Chris Daughtry previous background....america people don't want the same thing happen?
b). He able to be original copy.cat.com?
c). Gain a symphatize from american people?
d). American people was blind over his tear during the 3rd songs?

Here i realized and thingking that this is the biggest mistake in the american idol after Tylor Hick.

Anyway congratulation to Cook by winning this season. I believe he won't do as well as Chris Daughtry.....because he can't go far...

Archie? Also congratulation to him.... Even just runner-up....i believe you will make the biggest impact in your music carreer....

For those vote Cook all this while....congratulation to you all....because what you want.....already there...

And for those vote Archie..... i believe this is the right choice has been done by you all....

So...American idol show already finish....next we take a look what happen to Archie and Cook....

Sorry if my english not soo good...Its just my opinion...

It doesn't matter who won.

It doesn't matter who won. They'll both be forgotten in a year or two. David cook wears more eyeliner than MiMi from Drew Carey!

DAVID COOK IS AMAZING. and

DAVID COOK IS AMAZING.
and I'm so glad he won.
Not only is he unique and extremely good looking, but he is so talented.
I can tell he will be successful by far.
Don't get me wrong, David Archuletta is very talented, but he's young and I got bored with his performances.

I agree totally with America

I agree totally with America making the wrong choice. Not that David C. is not a talented individual, but if you go on pure singing quality and ability, David A. is far and away the superior talent. Even Randy Jeckson realizes that, when he commented the goal of Idol is to find each year the best singer and the best is David Archuleta.... And how about the idiotic comments that David C. is the only "musician" of the 2 Davids...I guess in their sad minds only someone who can play a guitar is a musician? And I suppose the piano doesn't count as a musical instrument? Fact is, David Archuleta is a true musician in the truest sense, and what is intimidating to the haters is that the kid is only 17! After David C. is "old" and washed up, this kid will still be in his prime. If you judge success on the future, David Archuleta's future is not only brighter, but LONGER! Take away David C.'s guitar, and you have a a good singer who is a dime a dozen. I know anyone with half a brain would acknowledge that even the least of talent can strum a guitar, bounce around the stage, and scream into a microphone and still be considered a success. That is what Rock and Roll is, and it doesn't take an extreme talent to do so. On the other hand, take away David A.'s piano, which he did most of the time, and you have a GREAT singer who can still carry the stage and the day, which doesn't come along but every once in a while. Quality singers have staying power. Perhaps the reason you David A. haters are so spiteful is that you all realize this kid is going to be around a very long time. So you better get use to it! Deal with it!

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <b> <i> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img> <p> <br> <blockquote> <object>

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
Members don't have to enter this spam prevention question so why not sign up :)
The Critic's blog