1. All caps very annoying.
2. Sentence structure horrible.
3. Fairly certain if a 17 year old little boy stripped on live television there would be a dew people sued and fired… funny! but no.
4. You are confused, it is David Cook that comes up with his own arrangements, that's kinda why the judges and TV personalities keep praising him on it. You need to pay attention, you not getting enough sleep at night?
5. I think you will find that most people (anyone with an IQ), will agree that young David A. can sing up a storm with that voice of his. He is simply not dynamic. Now you might defend that by saying he sings balads… fair enough, he is also not charasmatic yet nor does he have coordination or 'sex appeal' to pull off the deep emotive feel when he performs. He will, he just needs to grow.

You are most likely young yourself (just an assumption), but it's actually not even a fair comparison when you take someone as young as D.A. and put him against David C. and it has nothing to do with singing. A 20 year old is more comfortable with themselves and their sexualtiy and are able to express themselves better. Sorry. Just the way it is.