David Cook kinda grows on you.. at first I didn't care for what I also percieved as his "cocky" attitude but have since been able to see moments of true gratitude when listening to the judges critiques. Both Davids are taking everything the judges say and internalising it.. and making a sincere effort to improve their performances. My first choice however remains David A. but that's only because I like ballads over all more then pure rock and roll. However you can bet that when I am in the mood for pure rock... I'll listen to a cd by David cook in a heartbeat. As for Syesha.. she's come a LONG way in the last several weeks. She's improved by leaps and bounds in her confidence, comfort levels, range, pitch... song choice and poise... I just think it's too little to late. I think she'll still have a wonderful career ahead of her.. and Jason Castro.. man... wow! you blew it.