I was very happy that Carly got kicked off, but at the same time, I wasnt. Brooke should have left. Pouty faces can only take you so far in this competition.

My favorite would have to be David Cook, BUT I DO NOT WANT HIM TO WIN! Get real people. A close friend of mine auditioned for the show, and before everyone went in to audition you know what the producers told them? "Look, we are not looking for talent, we are looking for good Television". What does that tell you? Whoever wins American Idol will be extremely controlled in what they are able to do in their career, which is why i do not want David C. to win, because he is amazing and deserves a REAL record deal, not record deal held tightly on an American Idol leash.