Chris...American Idol is more based on popularity than talet i think....you as usual had an awsome night last night and had an awsome performance, you did not deserve to go home at all tonight, and it was such a big shock to me and everyone else that you left. Based on last nights performance I agree with Simon that Catherine should have gone home, but continue on with your dream and dont give up because you are an awsome performer and you made it this far and you are still the America Idol in my eyes. In no was do I think that Taylor or Elliot deserve to win!