I really think the three judges are wonderful- all are gifted with great abilities to pick musically talented people. They do, however, contradict themselves- last week some of the contestants were dancing with their songs and Simon said it was not a dance contest- this week Taylor stays in one place (no dancing) to sing and is marked down for not showing his usual stage presence- Taylor Hicks is a class act with a somewhat different style- we need talent like that.....

Jamie