I really gotta say, I agree with Simon about Gina.. That was TERRIBLE. There were parts of it that were good but come on, too much of it was random off-key screaming that sounded NOTHING like the song. Simon tells it like it is about how they SING. It's just too bad people vote based on who they feel bad for or who looks good -- and the contestants know that. The fact that Gina and Sanjaya are still here proves it. I really think she didn't get kicked the hell off this week only because she gave that whole "i don't give a crapi think i did great" speech. Keep brushing off VALID criticism like you're above it instead of improving yourself sweetie, you'll be kicking yourself in a month.

Haley would make a good, quick romp. Then send her out the door.

It might be fun for a queerbot to poke that Sanjaya boy in the keester, too.

Seacrest wants to. You know he does.

Oh, well. Doolitlte and Lakisha can sing, but they are a dime a dozen.

Nobody else is any good.

The whole night was a bit pleasing compared to last week. and that includes the "wild" sanjaya performance. I'm tired of Sanjaya bashing. Let him have his fun onstage. Btw Does he enjoy masochistic pleasures from the critiques?

But ugh, seriously I don't wanna see him in the Idol Tours. I'm not gonna pay for the tickets and listen to him sing. Maybe my curry eating friends would buy his English records (not!).

As usual, Lakisha and Melinda rock! And Blake finally scored higher than Chris Richardson in my book this week. wtg man! Chris has been picking very good songs for him the past weeks.

To reiterate my previous post, UNIQUENESS separate one artist from the rest. Watchout copycats, you're on the chopping block.

Sanjaya is awesome. I voted for him over 1000 times last night on Dial Idol. That little blonde girl who was crying over Sanjaya and who came up on the stage at the end will be back!

Sanjaya stays because of all of the telemarketers in India keep calling in...and as anyone who has tried to receive customer support by phone will tell you...that's a lot of votes!

I agree Sanjaya sucks! What the hell is keeping him in the running, everyone says he sucks, all I can think is that he has allot of family that is voting over and over for him.

I think that Stephanie Sounds too much like Beyonce, and its never orginal for me. She has the Beyonce-ish virbrato, and its annoying! We already have a Beyonce'. One is enough! Melinda is fantastic, Lakisha is just a Diva. Blake is the bomb! Sanjaya...no comment. Chris Sligh, I like his voice. Phil, He has a great voice too. Jordin is just a breath of fresh air! She is going to make it. She has a Whitney Houston thing going on. Jordin got it going on! Haley looked sexy tonight. She's another one up there with Sanjaya.

Did anyone else notice that in Doolittle's preformance and in the wrap up portion of the show she was using different hands to hold the mic? I don't think that it was a case of reversing the frame because the letters in the words American Idol were orientated correctly both times. I was under the impression that the show was a live show, with the ability to edit bad words, nudity etc. Could someone shed some light.

I THINK THE TOP 5 tonite were MeLinda Doolittle, Lakisha Jones, Jordin Sparks, Blake Lewis,Chris Sligh.

Sanjaya sucks!!! He should have never made it to Hollywood, let alone make it this far!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

My Favorite!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!